Sexual orientation and gender identity as a reason for asylum

Human rights of lesbian, gay, bisexual, transgender and intersex people (LGBTI) are under pressure in many countries. Breaches of their rights range from subtle discrimination to punishment, torture and imprisonment, and in some countries even the death penalty. The Netherlands provides protection to people who have a well-founded reason to fear persecution in their country of origin because of their sexual orientation or gender identity.

The IND assesses whether an asylum seeker is eligible for a residence permit because of their sexual orientation. This is no easy task. The IND staff member assesses whether the statements the asylum seeker made about their sexual orientation and the problems in the country of origin are credible. The staff member uses the work instruction on hearing and deciding in cases in which LGBTI orientation is put forward as a reason for asylum, among other things.

Support and assessment

Sexual orientation cannot be proven by means of documents. Hence, the IND gives the asylum seeker ample opportunity to tell about their stated sexual orientation or gender identity. Different themes are addressed, for example the situation of LGBTI people in the country of origin. It is up to the asylum seeker to make their sexual orientation or gender identity credible. This can sometimes be difficult for LGBTI people because we  cannot assess from the outside what the asylum seeker’s (inner) identity is.

In the assessment of an asylum application, we take into account that it is not possible for an asylum seeker to provide conclusive evidence that they are LGBTI. The IND staff member will never ask for details about an asylum seeker’s sex life. Nor does the IND carry out medical tests (including psychological examination).

Individual approach

No two people are the same. Knowledge about the LGBTI community in their country of origin can vary between asylum seekers, just like their contacts or relationships with people of the same sex. That is why the IND is looking for the asylum seeker’s authentic story and tries to adapt questions to the individual situation in doing so. The IND staff member takes into account cultural differences and how people think and express themselves.

Investigation of credibility of sexual orientation

We will first investigate whether the sexual orientation is credible because it also happens that an asylum seeker only uses this reason to obtain a residence permit. The questions we ask address the problems the asylum seeker says to have had in their country of origin. Then we check whether these match what is known about the general situation of LGBTI people in the country of origin.

We also investigate how the asylum seeker has expressed their sexual orientation in the past and now. Next, we will investigate what awaits the asylum seeker should they return, for example persecution, and how serious the situation is in the country of origin.

Safe environment

Because LGBTI people are often from an environment where being gay, lesbian or transgender is taboo, many of them find it difficult to talk freely about their sexual orientation. Especially if they have had negative experiences with the authorities in their country, they may not feel free to tell their story without restraint.

Interviewing vulnerable asylum seekers

IND staff receive training that extensively covers these difficulties and hearing vulnerable asylum seekers. It also includes the ways to record an asylum seeker’s story well on paper, also when shame is in play, for example. Also addressed are ways to create the right atmosphere during the interview and give someone room to tell their story. The training also addresses stereotypes and the role of the interpreter. 

More information

COC Netherlands
ilga.org (overview of LGBTI legislation worldwide)

 

vlag met regenboogkleuren

 

Important topics

Family reunification

Anyone who is not safe in their own country can obtain protection in the Netherlands (asylum). Asylum seekers who have a right to this can build a future in the Netherlands. Sometimes, reunification with family members who have stayed behind is part…

Unaccompanied minors

It often happens that children travel to the Netherlands on their own, without their parents. More often than not, these so-called unaccompanied minors (in Dutch: alleenstaande minderjarige vreemdelingen, or AMVs) come to Europe with the help of…

Article 1F

By signing the UN Refugee Convention, the Netherlands undertook to offer protection to persons who fled their country because of persecution or a fear of persecution. However, some may be guilty of war crimes or crimes against humanity, as referred…